To pay for my company’s taxes, my accountant logs into the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) website and types into forms on the computer screen. Once filled, she checks and mouse clicks a button to submit the form. She logs out of the BIR website and then tells me to log into the company’s bank portal so that I can pay for the tax online.
It’s supposed to be more convenient. It’s supposed to save time. Instead of filling out paper forms by hand, preparing checks, having the forms & checks signed by authorised parties, and travelling to & falling in line at the nearest bank branch to pay, my accountant & I can file and remit taxes in a jiffy from one place (or from any place for that matter).
I don’t need to file paper forms in file cabinets. I could download the submitted tax forms with acknowledged receipts and file them away in my computer’s hard drive without having to print them. I save on paper and office storage space.
It’s similar when I pay for my company’s electric and phone bills. The electric & phone companies email to notify me bills are ready to download & pay for at their respective portals. I log in, download, and pay for the bills online. Just as with the BIT, I supposedly save time not having to wait for paper bills, not preparing bank checks, not having them signed by authorised parties, and not falling in line to pay at the respective electric or phone company’s payment centres.
I could never go back to manual paper transactions but that is more because the BIR, the utility companies, and the banks will no longer let me. It has become standard policy to pay online. Processing paper transactions have been rendered obsolete and is seen as an unproductive activity relative to online transactions.
It’s not totally true, however, that online transactions had become more productive.
Taxpayers & consumers, or users in general, require e Internet access. If an internet service provider (ISP) does not provide high-speed services, users could find themselves staring at their device screens, spending time waiting for portals to respond.
It’s also not necessarily getting what you pay for. ISPs don’t guarantee the highest data speeds, and they made sure that no-guarantee is in their subscribers’ contracts.
Users also need to regularly update their apps and invest to ensure their devices’ hardware are state-of-the-art, or at least compatible with app programming requirements.
Banks and utility companies had also implemented stringent security requirements when accessing and transacting their portals. Some demand users submit one-time passwords (OTPs) on top of log-in credentials. Every month I find myself logging in multiple times to one phone company’s portal because the OTP would arrive late.
The bank where I pay my BIR taxes doesn’t allow online transactions after 6pm or on weekends & holidays. I can only pay taxes during the daytime which means I don’t have the convenience of paying whenever I want to before deadlines.
Banks also often schedule “maintenance” downtimes during weekends, in which their portals go offline for hours such as from Saturday evening to Sunday morning. Not only I wouldn’t be able to pay taxes or utility bills during these periods, I also won’t be able to use my cash or credit cards too.
The BIR website also sometimes “hangs” or goes offline especially close to tax filing deadlines. And the BIR policy makers have a bad habit of implementing new regulations at very short notices. Many taxpayers therefore deliberately don’t file early because if a new rule comes out, they’d have to re-file and re-submit proofs of payment. Sometimes, the BIR would tell taxpayers to submit paper forms to the nearest BIR office as a workaround during transitions between old and new rules. And then tell taxpayers to re-file online. Taxpayers end up filing twice.
The utility companies’ portals seldom “hang” but they’d still push deadlines at very short notices, like within a week or two. They’d slap penalties or threaten disconnections if users pay late. I and my staff, therefore, don’t have the convenience to schedule payments throughout a calendar month. Most of the time, we’d be rushing to pay online the first two (2) weeks of every month.
The BIR also from time to time requires taxpayers to reconcile their transactions against the agency’s records. BIR auditors ask taxpayers to submit hard copies of documented transactions & payments. Taxpayers end up printing and submitting paperwork which was supposed to had been eliminated.
Online transactions benefit the hosts, not the users. Banks & utility companies gain productively because users do the work their tellers & cashiers formerly did before the Internet revolution. The BIR does not need to hire employees to receive and check forms; the taxpayers do that job for them. The banks, utilities companies, and the BIR save money; the users do not, as they do the same work which they had always been doing albeit online instead of manually on paper.
And because users must often go through multiple steps for purposes of security, for workarounds versus offline schedules & glitches, and to beat short-notice deadlines, any convenience or so-called productivity savings are never really felt. Users end up paying at least the same in terms of time and resources for work where the host institutions reap the advantages.
Paperless productivity from online transactions is a myth, at least to users. I and many others who have not much choice to transact online, don’t experience any savings or gains. I wouldn’t ask institutions to share the benefits but I’d implore them to at least continuously improve their portals to make it easier for us users to work with.
Find Ellery