
A chief executive officer (CEO) tells the Chief Finance Officer (CFO) and the Chief Supply Chain Officer (CSCO) that the company needs to cut costs. Profit margins are too thin, the CEO says. He wants the CFO and the CSCO to submit action plans by next Friday.
The CFO submitted his suggested action plans:
- Reduce headcount across all operations
- Terminate leases of depots the company is renting
- Buy cheaper materials and negotiate bulk volume discounts
- Insist on lower freight rates from truckers
The CSCO submitted his suggested action plans:
- Increase batch sizes to lengthen production runs
- Increase minimum order requirements from customers to maximise freight utilisation
- Implement a no-return no-exchange policy
- Stop monthly sales incentives leading to month-end shipping rushes
The CFO and CSCO balked at each other’s action plans.
The CFO said that increasing production batch sizes and minimum order quantities will increase inventories and working capital. A no-return no-exchange policy and an end to monthly sales incentives would lead to lower revenues.
The CSCO said that reducing headcount will deprive needed talent for operations and result in overtime from remaining employees. Terminating depot leases would restrict available inventories at key locations. Insisting on lower freight rates from truckers would lead to fewer vehicles for deliveries. Buying cheaper materials would result in poorer product quality.
Whose cost cutting action plans should the CEO favour?
Cutting costs is never easier than it seems.